Carinsider

EV Charging Is Opening a Quiet Expenses Fraud Gap for Fleets

Fleet·November 19, 2026

EV Charging Is Opening a Quiet Expenses Fraud Gap for Fleets

Fleet managers are putting more electric vehicles on the road, but many still don't know what those cars truly cost to charge. A new survey of 250 fleet, finance and procurement leaders, commissioned by mobility software firm Cubic3, suggests that blind spot is becoming a fraud risk.

The most striking number is how much trust is involved. Forty-four percent of EV fleets rely on drivers to report how much they spend charging at home. Nearly half of respondents (48%) had expenses claims in the last year that they could not verify. Around a third (31%) reported unauthorised transactions on company credit, fuel or charging cards, and 30% had at least one suspected or confirmed case of fraud.

Confidence and control don't line up. Some 93% said they could spot unauthorised or fraudulent spending, and 64% believed they had full visibility of costs. Yet only 41% said their expenses were actually under control, and a third struggled to track spending accurately across vehicles and drivers. Electrification is making the job harder. Fifty-four percent said EV charging complicated payment and spend management, a process that already takes an average of 171 hours a year.

Home charging is the awkward part. The electricity a driver uses at home is hard to separate from the household's energy bill, which is why reimbursing it fairly has been a long-running headache. HMRC-approved advisory electric rates (AERs) offer a shortcut. They are published every quarter with separate per-mile rates for home and public charging, and they are designed to be a simple way to settle claims. But they are approximations, and the gap between the rate and reality can be large.

Take a driver paying the Ofgem price cap of 26.3p per kWh. To break even with the 7p per-mile home charging rate, they would need to average 3.8 miles per kWh, including charging losses. Drivers on a cheap overnight tariff, who can bring their costs below 2p per mile, would be over-reimbursed by the same figure.

Operators are allowed to set their own rates, but HMRC expects them to show those rates reflect real-world costs. If they can't, any excess payment could be treated as untaxed income. Only 20% of the surveyed fleets said they used a tariff or meter to work out what home charging actually costs.

The stakes will rise as fleets electrify. Respondents expect electric vehicles to make up an average of 49% of their fleets within three years. Cubic3 warns that a process already struggling at today's levels will look far shakier at that scale.

Paul Foley, the company's vice-president of in-vehicle payments, put the problem plainly. "The gap between confidence and control is the real finding," he said. Fleets, he argued, need to check each payment against company rules before the money leaves, rather than trying to reconcile it afterwards.

Reporting based on an external source.