Same Heart, Different Cars: The E39 M5 and Z8 Share More Than You'd Expect
Classic Cars·October 23, 2026

BMW didn't need two different engines to build two very different 394-horsepower cars. The E39 M5 and the E52 Z8 both run the 4.9-liter S62 V8, and both deliver the same 369 lb-ft (500 Nm) of torque. On a spec sheet, that makes them close relatives.
Look past the engine and the resemblance fades quickly. The E39 M5 is a four-door performance sedan meant to cover long distances in comfort while still getting the job done on a back road. The Z8 is a two-seat roadster, with a body and driving character built around open-air touring and the feel of a modern classic. Different buyers, different priorities, and different cars built around them.
That's the real story here. The shared V8 is less a common platform than a shared heart. BMW of that era had a habit of reusing strong powertrains across its lineup, letting one well-regarded engine carry the reputation of several models while the chassis, bodywork, and tuning changed to suit each car's purpose. The S62 gave the M5 its muscle and the Z8 its punch, but neither car feels like the other once you're behind the wheel.
For enthusiasts, the comparison is a useful reminder that horsepower and torque figures only tell part of the story. Weight, suspension, gearing, and how the car communicates with its driver all shape the experience. Two cars with identical engine numbers can feel like they came from different companies.
For anyone considering either car as a used purchase, the takeaway is simple. The S62 is the common thread, so the engine's strengths apply to both, but the decision should come down to the body style you want, the condition of the chassis, and the maintenance history of the individual car. The engine is only one part of the choice.
Reporting based on an external source.