Diesel's Fuel Edge Has Vanished. Torque Is Its Last Stand.
Running Costs·October 25, 2026

A recent test of the Skoda Octavia estate reopened an awkward question: with pump prices where they are, why would anyone buy a new diesel? The car in question, a 2.0 TDI 150PS DSG Sportline costing £38,645, is rated at 60.1mpg. Its mild-hybrid petrol sibling, the 1.5 TSI e-Tec 150PS DSG Sportline at £37,265, manages 54.3mpg. On paper, that is a clear diesel advantage. In practice, the numbers are close to a wash.
The reason is price at the pump. Diesel is currently around 199 pence a litre, against about 174 pence for petrol. Run both cars over 10,000 miles and the diesel Octavia costs roughly £1,505 in fuel, while the petrol costs about £1,457. The diesel's efficiency lead is real, but it is almost entirely cancelled out by the higher fuel price.
It was not always this way. Ten years ago both fuels cost around 112 pence a litre, and the diesel's superior economy made its higher list price easy to justify. Diesel engines were also simpler to live with. Today the calculation is murkier. Diesel engines have a weaker reputation for reliability in many buyers' minds, and manufacturers are building fewer of them. Company car drivers, who once bought diesels in large numbers, are being pushed toward electric models by lower benefit-in-kind tax rates.
The used market tells a similar story. Diesel sales slowed noticeably this summer, and the models most likely to hold their value are large estates and SUVs with strong towing capacity. Anything else is probably facing steeper depreciation.
That leaves the diesel's strongest argument: pulling power. The Octavia diesel produces 266lb ft of torque, against 184lb ft for the petrol. That matters if you tow a caravan or a boat, if you regularly drive long distances with four adults and a full boot, or if you simply prefer an engine that pulls effortlessly from low revs without much throttle input.
Finance is where the outcome becomes almost comical. A slightly larger deposit paired with a bigger balloon payment means the diesel's monthly cost on a four-year PCP deal is £361, against £363 for the petrol. The two are effectively identical.
So the answer is not really about the spreadsheet. Diesel no longer wins on running costs for most drivers. It still earns its place for those who need its torque, and for everyone else the petrol is the simpler, cheaper-to-own choice.
Reporting based on an external source.